Your Receivables Aren't Slow — They're Gone
Your Receivables Aren't Slow — They're Gone
Sometime in late October 2008, my receivables went from 45 days to 110 days in about six weeks. On paper, nothing changed. The money was still there in the AR report, sitting in a column labeled "outstanding." I had two builder accounts that together represented maybe $140,000 in work I'd done and hadn't been paid for. I thought I had a cash-flow timing problem. What I actually had was the first sign that two builders were going under.
I found out what "timing problem" really meant when one of them filed Chapter 11 the following spring.
That's the story of most dead shops. Not a skills problem. Not a market problem. Just a gap between what the AR report said and what was actually coming in — and an owner making decisions based on a number that wasn't real.
The Moment You Extended Terms, You Made a Loan
Here's the frame for this whole piece.
The second you let a customer pay past your terms — past your 30-day net, past your due-on-completion, past whatever you put in the contract — you stopped being a contractor and started being a lender. An unsecured one. No credit application. No personal guarantee. None of the instruments a bank would require before letting someone borrow $18,000 worth of your labor and materials.
Banks have underwriters. They have collateral. They have legal standing baked in from day one. You have an invoice and a relationship you don't want to damage.
You're outgunned.
Ask yourself the question I keep asking guys I talk to: how long could you pay your crew, your truck notes, your insurance, with zero new revenue? Ninety days is the floor. That's where you have a business. Below that you have a hostage situation — you're dependent on the next job to fund the last one, which means every slow-pay customer owns a piece of your decision-making. You gave them that. They didn't take it.
The 2008 crash didn't kill bad shops. Bad shops survived fine — low overhead, nothing to lose, they adjusted. What the crash killed was undercapitalized shops. Shops doing real volume, hiring real people, carrying their cash in receivables from builders who were about to stop returning calls. Slow receivables are how a shop bleeds out — not overnight, not in a crisis, but a little at a time, week by week, while the owner still thinks he's having a decent year because the AR number looks fine.
The AR number is not fine.
The Number in Your AR Report Is a Lie
Pull up your AR report right now.
Find everything over 60 days. Mark it red. Now don't count it.
Add up what's left — current, 30-day, maybe-45-day. That total is your actual business. The red column isn't slow money. It's a collection problem mislabeled as an accounting problem. Fiction on a balance sheet. And you're making real decisions — hiring, equipment, whether to bid that commercial job — based on numbers that aren't going to show up.
When my receivables stretched to 110 days in fall 2008, the dollar amounts on the books didn't change. That's the cruel part. The report still showed the money. Two builders were running out of road, paying their secured creditors first, using my unpaid invoices as float — but my books didn't know it yet. I was staring at a number that felt like an asset and was becoming a write-off in real time.
I've watched shops carrying $80,000 in 90-day-plus AR celebrate a good month in revenue while they're actually going broke. Revenue line looks fine. Cash doesn't come. Payroll still goes out.
Receivables over 60 days aren't slow customers. They're uncollectible jobs you're still pretending are assets. The longer you pretend, the worse the math gets.
Go back and run the 90-day question against what's liquid after you apply the red-line test. If your real business just shrank by $40,000, how long can you run the shop? If the answer is three weeks, you are not in a cash-flow problem. You are in a survival problem. And it started six months ago when you let someone slide past 30 days and told yourself they were good for it.
What "He's Good for It" Actually Means
Most contractors extend terms because they think they're being decent. Long-term customer, good history, rough patch — who wants to be the guy who sends a hard letter to someone they've worked with for eight years?
I understand that. I've been that guy.
What feels like generosity is usually conflict avoidance. And the customer knows the difference even when you don't.
General contractors who pay in 60-plus days aren't slow. They've made a calculated decision that you won't enforce your terms. They have cash. They're allocating it. The framer threatened to walk last month and got a check by Thursday. You sent a polite email and got "next Friday." They're paying people who apply pressure and floating the ones who don't. Every week you let it slide, you're proving the bet right.
Same with residential customers. The moment you blink — the moment you say "don't worry about it, pay me when you can" — you've told them your terms are a suggestion. After that you're starting from zero every time an invoice comes due.
I fired Whitman Builders in 2011. By then I was already into the bankruptcy recovery. The point isn't that firing them fixed the $61,000 problem — it didn't. I got thirty-eight cents on the dollar and a hard lesson. The point is that keeping them would have added to the loss. Every week I kept sending guys to their sites, I was compounding a number I didn't know was already uncollectible.
A relationship that requires you to absorb unpaid invoices to maintain it isn't a relationship. It's a subsidy. You're funding someone else's operation and calling it a partnership.
The Whitman Story
In 2011 I was owed $61,000 by a builder named Whitman out of Marlborough. Not a fly-by-night outfit — they'd been around, I'd done work with them for a few years, real volume, houses in the $400,000 to $600,000 range. I'd rebuilt slowly after the 2008 layoffs and had three guys I'd kept through the worst of it. I couldn't afford to lose the volume.
The calls went like this: "Next Friday." "End of the month, we've got a closing." "Phase Two is almost funded, you'll see a big check." I kept working. My guys needed hours. I told myself I knew these people.
What I couldn't see was that Whitman was already behind on their construction loans. They were paying the creditors who were making noise and floating everyone who wasn't. I wasn't making noise. I was being patient. Every week I kept going, I was making the bet bigger on their behalf.
They filed. I filed a claim. Thirty-eight cents on the dollar.
On $61,000 owed, I got back roughly $23,000. I ate $38,000. Plus materials I'd roughed in on two active jobs in the two weeks before everything stopped — still working while the decision was already made somewhere I couldn't see it.
Here's the thing the Whitman story taught me that I didn't expect: your largest accounts are the ones you're least likely to press. The bigger the relationship, the harder it is to send the letter. That means your biggest exposure is exactly where you're applying the least pressure. That's the wrong way around. The bigger the number at risk, the faster you move. Not slower.
The Mechanics Lien Is the Tool You Have and Aren't Using
Small contractors have something banks don't: the mechanics lien. A legal claim against the property for labor and materials furnished. It's real. It works. Most shops either don't file, file too late, or don't know their state's deadline until they've blown past it.
Deadlines vary. Some states give you 90 days from last work. Some give you 120. Some require you to send a preliminary notice before you even start work or you lose the right entirely. The point is you need to know your state's rules now — not when a customer hits 90 days slow, because by then you may already be out of time.
Look it up this week. Or call a construction attorney who does lien work and spend an hour on the phone. Do it before you need it.
When you do need it, here's how it goes. Send a written demand first — certified mail, return receipt, every invoice itemized with dollar figures and dates, a hard deadline of seven business days, and the word "lien" written plainly. Don't soften it. They already know they're slow. You're not delivering news, you're delivering consequences.
If the deadline passes, file. Don't threaten to file. File.
Then stop work. All jobs. Tools off-site.
Most guys do this backwards. They stop work — which starts a fight — then scramble to figure out the legal side while they're already in it. Or they file without the demand letter first, which can hurt you legally depending on your state. Or they do nothing until the window is almost closed and rush a defective lien put together in a panic.
Send the demand first. File second. Stop work in parallel with the filing. That order matters both legally and practically.
The demand letter is also a record. It shows you notified the customer, gave them a deadline, and they still didn't pay. That matters in small claims. That matters in any collection suit. Don't skip it even when you want to go straight to the lien.
What You Do This Week
Pull the AR report before anything else. Apply the 60-day red-line test. Add up what's left. That's your real business. Then run the 90-day question against what's actually liquid — payroll, truck notes, insurance. Get a real number. Write it down.
If that number scares you, that's correct. That's the number you've been avoiding.
For anything in the red column: send the written demand this week. Certified mail, return receipt, every invoice listed, specific dollars, seven-business-day deadline, the word "lien" in plain language. Don't apologize. The customer already knows they're behind.
For active jobs where a customer has gone slow: stop scheduling new work until the balance clears. When they ask why — and they will — tell them exactly why. Their account is past due and you're not adding to it until it's cleared.
If they get angry, pay attention. Anger means they expected you to keep going. That's the whole lesson. The framer threatened to walk and got paid. You kept working and got "next Friday."
Be the framer.
The money you're owed is either coming or it isn't. The AR report won't tell you which. What you do in the next seven days will.
A Few Questions I Get Asked
My customer says they're waiting on their insurance payout. Should I wait?
For a short window, with a hard date in writing — yes. Ask for the claim number, the adjuster's name, and written confirmation of expected timing. If they can give you that, you have something real. Set a specific calendar date — not "when insurance pays," an actual date — and put it in an email. If that date passes without payment or real documentation of a delay, you're not waiting on insurance anymore. You're extending credit to someone running out of excuses.
How do I handle a slow-pay customer I've worked with for eight years without blowing up the relationship?
Send the demand letter anyway. Eight years of history means you've earned the right to be direct, not the obligation to stay quiet. Most long-term customers respond to a firm, professional demand better than you expect. The ones who blow up over a certified letter were already telling you something about how they view the arrangement. Better to know that at $15,000 than at $60,000.
What if I don't have a signed contract — can I still file a mechanics lien?
In most states the lien right is tied to work performed and materials furnished, not to whether you have a signed contract. No written contract makes everything harder — the demand, the lien, any court proceeding. File the lien if you're within the deadline. But get a contract template this week and stop working without one.
What dollar amount is worth filing a lien over?
Any amount that would hurt to eat. The lien on a $1,800 invoice sends a message worth more than $1,800. If customers know you file when you're stiffed, they pay. If they know you write it off and disappear, they budget for it.
Should I use a collections agency for overdue invoices?
Last resort, not first response. Most agencies take 25 to 40 percent of what they collect, and they collect on roughly half of what you send them. You're realistically looking at 30 to 50 cents on the dollar if it works at all. That beats zero. But the demand letter, the lien, and stopping work are cheaper and faster and preserve more of the money. Exhaust those first.
My GC has a pay-when-paid clause. Does that kill my lien rights?
Generally no. The lien is a statutory right, not a contractual one, and most states protect it even when the contract tries to limit it. Pay-when-paid clauses have varying enforceability depending on your state — some restrict them hard, some give them full effect. Don't take my word on your state's specifics. Call a construction attorney who does lien work. One hour, a few hundred dollars. I've never known a shop owner who made that call and regretted it.
Enjoyed this article?
Get articles like this in your inbox every Monday. Free, no spam.